diff --git a/lib/dotcom/schedule_finder/upcoming_departures.ex b/lib/dotcom/schedule_finder/upcoming_departures.ex
index 1402c4d33a..9330d5a08b 100644
--- a/lib/dotcom/schedule_finder/upcoming_departures.ex
+++ b/lib/dotcom/schedule_finder/upcoming_departures.ex
@@ -460,7 +460,7 @@ defmodule Dotcom.ScheduleFinder.UpcomingDepartures do
   defp arrival_substatus(%{
          predicted_schedule: %PredictedSchedule{prediction: %Prediction{status: status}}
        })
-       when status != nil,
+       when status != nil and status != "Delayed",
        do: {:status, status |> String.split(" ") |> Enum.map_join(" ", &String.capitalize/1)}
 
   defp arrival_substatus(%{
@@ -473,6 +473,7 @@ defmodule Dotcom.ScheduleFinder.UpcomingDepartures do
        }) do
     scheduled_time = schedule.departure_time
     predicted_time = prediction.departure_time
+    status = prediction.status
 
     cond do
       predicted_time == nil ->
@@ -484,6 +485,9 @@ defmodule Dotcom.ScheduleFinder.UpcomingDepartures do
       DateTime.diff(predicted_time, scheduled_time, :second) >= 60 ->
         {:delayed_from, scheduled_time}
 
+      status != nil ->
+        {:status, status}
+
       true ->
         :on_time
     end
diff --git a/test/dotcom/schedule_finder/upcoming_departures_test.exs b/test/dotcom/schedule_finder/upcoming_departures_test.exs
index 7167268900..5bd0014e78 100644
--- a/test/dotcom/schedule_finder/upcoming_departures_test.exs
+++ b/test/dotcom/schedule_finder/upcoming_departures_test.exs
@@ -1858,6 +1858,130 @@ defmodule Dotcom.ScheduleFinder.UpcomingDeparturesTest do
       assert departure.arrival_substatus == {:status, display_status}
     end
 
+    test "shows {:status, 'Delayed'} for commuter rail if the status is 'Delayed', but the predicted time is less than a minute late" do
+      # Setup
+      now = Dotcom.Utils.DateTime.now()
+
+      route = Factories.Routes.Route.build(:commuter_rail_route)
+      route_id = route.id
+      stop_id = FactoryHelpers.build(:id)
+
+      trip = Factories.Schedules.Trip.build(:trip)
+      direction_id = Faker.Util.pick([0, 1])
+
+      scheduled_departure_time =
+        Generators.DateTime.random_time_range_date_time(
+          {now, ServiceDateTime.end_of_service_day(now)}
+        )
+
+      predicted_departure_time =
+        scheduled_departure_time
+        |> DateTime.shift(second: Faker.random_between(0, 59))
+
+      expect(Predictions.Repo.Mock, :all, fn [
+                                               route: ^route_id,
+                                               direction_id: ^direction_id,
+                                               include_terminals: true
+                                             ] ->
+        [
+          Factories.Predictions.Prediction.build(:prediction,
+            departure_time: predicted_departure_time,
+            stop: Factories.Stops.Stop.build(:stop, id: stop_id),
+            status: "Delayed",
+            trip: trip
+          )
+        ]
+      end)
+
+      expect(Schedules.Repo.Mock, :by_route_ids, fn
+        _, _ ->
+          [
+            Factories.Schedules.Schedule.build(:schedule,
+              departure_time: scheduled_departure_time,
+              time: scheduled_departure_time,
+              stop: Factories.Stops.Stop.build(:stop, id: stop_id),
+              trip: trip
+            )
+          ]
+      end)
+
+      # Exercise
+      departures =
+        UpcomingDepartures.upcoming_departures(%{
+          direction_id: direction_id,
+          now: now,
+          route: route,
+          stop_id: stop_id
+        })
+
+      # Verify
+      assert [departure] = departures
+      assert departure.arrival_status == {:time, predicted_departure_time}
+      assert departure.arrival_substatus == {:status, "Delayed"}
+    end
+
+    test "shows {:delayed_from, scheduled_time} for commuter rail if predicted time is more than a minute late even if the status is 'Delayed'" do
+      # Setup
+      now = Dotcom.Utils.DateTime.now()
+
+      route = Factories.Routes.Route.build(:commuter_rail_route)
+      route_id = route.id
+      stop_id = FactoryHelpers.build(:id)
+
+      trip = Factories.Schedules.Trip.build(:trip)
+      direction_id = Faker.Util.pick([0, 1])
+
+      scheduled_departure_time =
+        Generators.DateTime.random_time_range_date_time(
+          {now, ServiceDateTime.end_of_service_day(now)}
+        )
+
+      predicted_departure_time =
+        scheduled_departure_time
+        |> DateTime.shift(second: Faker.random_between(60, 3600))
+
+      expect(Predictions.Repo.Mock, :all, fn [
+                                               route: ^route_id,
+                                               direction_id: ^direction_id,
+                                               include_terminals: true
+                                             ] ->
+        [
+          Factories.Predictions.Prediction.build(:prediction,
+            departure_time: predicted_departure_time,
+            stop: Factories.Stops.Stop.build(:stop, id: stop_id),
+            status: "Delayed",
+            trip: trip
+          )
+        ]
+      end)
+
+      expect(Schedules.Repo.Mock, :by_route_ids, fn
+        _, _ ->
+          [
+            Factories.Schedules.Schedule.build(:schedule,
+              departure_time: scheduled_departure_time,
+              time: scheduled_departure_time,
+              stop: Factories.Stops.Stop.build(:stop, id: stop_id),
+              trip: trip
+            )
+          ]
+      end)
+
+      # Exercise
+      departures =
+        UpcomingDepartures.upcoming_departures(%{
+          direction_id: direction_id,
+          now: now,
+          route: route,
+          stop_id: stop_id
+        })
+
+      # Verify
+      assert [departure] = departures
+      assert departure.arrival_status == {:time, predicted_departure_time}
+      assert departure.arrival_substatus == {:delayed_from, scheduled_departure_time}
+    end
+
     test "shows :cancelled for commuter rail or bus if the schedule_relationship is :cancelled or :skipped" do
       # Setup
       now = Dotcom.Utils.DateTime.now()