Skip to content
Open
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
157 changes: 157 additions & 0 deletions netlify-vs-vercel-case-study.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,157 @@
---
Netlify vs. Vercel: A Case Study on Modern Web Hosting
Author: Jenny Johnsby <JennyJohnsby>
Tags: netlify, vercel, web hosting, deployment, jamstack
---

## Introduction
This case study examines Netlify and Vercel, two leading web hosting and deployment platforms designed for modern web development, especially for Jamstack-based projects.
Both platforms are popular among developers for their ease of use, automated deployments, and supportt for static and dynamic web applications.
This analysis will explore their history, feature, market positioning, and how they compare to each other.

## Expressions Explained
Jamstack - Jamstack is a modern web development architecture that stands for JavaScript, APIs, and Markup. It promotes pre-rendered static sites and serverless functions to improve speed, security, and scalability.
Static Site Generation <SSG> - SSG is a method where web pages are pre-built at deployment time rather than being generated dynamically for each request. This makes websites faster and more secure. Frameworks like Gatsby, Jekyll, and Hugo commonly use SSG.
Server-Side Rendering <SSR> - SSR is a technique where web pages are generated on the server before being sent to the user's browser. This allows for dynamic content and better SEO. Vercel is optimized for SSR, especially with Next.js.
Incremental Static Regeneration <ISR> - ISR is a hybrid approach that allows statically generated pages to be updated at runtime without rebuilding the entire site. This is useful for sites that need fresh content but still want fast performance. Vercel supports ISR natively for Next.js projects.
Edge Functions / Edge Computing - Edge computing processes data closer to the user by running small serverless functions on a global network of edge locations rather than a central server. This results in faster load times and lower latency for users worldwide.
Cold Start - A cold start happens when a serverless function takes extra time to execute because it hasn’t been used recently. This can cause delays for users. Vercel’s Edge Functions tend to have faster cold start times than Netlify’s AWS Lambda-based functions.
Global Content Delivery Network <CDN> - A CDN is a network of distributed servers that cache website content closer to the user’s location. Both Netlify and Vercel use CDNs to ensure fast loading speeds globally.
Serverless Functions - Serverless functions allow developers to run backend code without managing servers. They are event-driven and only execute when needed, which reduces costs. Netlify uses AWS Lambda, while Vercel offers its own Edge & Serverless Functions.
Git-based Deployments - Both Netlify and Vercel allow developers to automatically deploy their websites from Git repositories. Whenever code is updated, the platform rebuilds and redeploys the site automatically.
Continuous Integration / Continuous Deployment <CI/CD> - CI/CD is a development practice where code is automatically tested and deployed every time a developer makes a change. Netlify and Vercel both offer automated CI/CD pipelines to streamline the development process.
Custom Domains & SSL - Both platforms allow users to connect their own domain name and include free SSL certificates <which encrypt data between the website and the user>.


## Brief history
- 2014: Netlify is founded by Mathias Biilmann and Christian Bach to simplify static hosting.
- 2015: Vercel <formerly ZEIT> is founded by Guillermo Rauch focusing on seamless frontend deployments.
- 2016: Netlify introdyces the therm "Jamstack" and promotes its use in modern web development.
- 2020: ZEIT rebrands as Vercel and focuses on preformance-driven frontend deployment, particularly for Next.js applications.
- 2021: Both platforms continue to evolve with new features, including serverledd functions, edge computing, and improved deployment capabilities.

## Main Features

### Netlify
- **Git-based Deployments** - Connects to Github, Gitlab, or Bitbucket for automatic deployment.
- **Serverless functions** - Supports AWS Lambda functionsfor backend logic.
- **Netlify Edge** - Provides a global CDN for fast delvivery.
- **Forms and Identity** - Built in support form submissions and authentication.

### Vercel
- **Git-based Deployments** - Optimized for Next.js, with automatic ISR, SSR, and API routes.
- **Vercel Edge Functions** - Similar to Netlifys edge network, providing fast global distribution.
- **Dynamic Deployments** - Supports both static and server-rendered apps efficiently.

|Feature | Netlify | Vercel |
|-----------------------------------|----------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------|
|**Best for** | Static sites, general Jamstackprojects.| Next.js projects, dynamic frontend apps.|
|**Serverless Functions** | Yes <AWS Lambda-based> | Yes <Edge & Serverless Functions> |
|**Edge Network** | Yes | Yes |
|**Automatic Deployments** | Yes | Yes |
|**Custom Domains & SSL** | Yes | Yes |
|**Built-in Analytics** | Yes <Paid> | Yes <Paid> |


## Market Comparison

### Performance and Pricing Comparison
#### Deployment Speed
Both Netlify and Vercel offer automatic deployments from GitHub, GitLab, and Bitbucket.
However, Vercel is optimized for Next.js and offers fater build times for Next.js project, thanks to ISR.
Netlify, on the other hand, is slightly better for SSG and offers a smoother experience for frameworks like Hugo or Jekyll

|Metric | Netlify | Vercel |
|--------------------------------|-------------------------|-----------------------------|
|Build Time <Next.js> | ~2 min <with caching> | ~1.5 min <ISR optimizations>|
|Build Time <Gatsby> | ~1.8 min | ~2 min |
|Cold Start <Serverless> | ~300ms <AWS Lambda> | ~200ms <Edge Functions> |
|Global CDN Propagation | ~1 min | ~30 sec |

### Pricing Breakdown
Both platforms offer free tiers, but costs can rise depending og usage.

|Feature | Netlify | Vercel |
|--------------------------------|---------------------------------|-----------------------------|
|Free Tier | 125k requests, 100GB bandwith | 100GB bandwith, 1000 builds |
|Pro Plan | $19/month per member | $20/month per member |
|Serverless Execution | $1.50/million requests | $5/million invocations |
|Edge Functions | Limited on free plan | More generous free limit |

### Netlify vs. Vercel: Pros & Cons
#### Netlify
✔️ Best suited for static sites and Jamstack applications.
✔️ Easy-to-use form handling and authentication.
✔️ Strong developer experience with plugins and intergations.
❌ Not as optimized for Next.js compared to Vercel.
❌ Slightly slower cold starts for serverless functions.

#### Vercel
✔️ The best choice for Next.js projects with built-in optimizations.
✔️ Superior support for dynamic rendering <ISR, SSR>.
✔️ Fastes global edge deployments.
❌ Fewer built-in features <e.g., forms, identity> compared to Netlify.
❌ Can be more expensive at scale due to server-side rendering needs.

## Getting Started

### Deploying a Site on Netlify
1. Sign up at [Netlify](https://www.netlify.com/).
2. Connect your Github repository.
3. Configure build settings <e.g., `npm run build`>.
4. Deploy and get a live oreview URL.

### Deploying a Site on Vercel
1. Sign up at [Vercel](https://vercel.com/).
2. Import a Github repository.
3. Set up your framework <especially for Next.js>
4. Deploy Instantly with automatic previews.

## Conclusion

Netlify and Vercel are two of the leading platforms for deploying modern web applications, each catering to slightly different development needs.

- ** Use Netlify ** - if you are building a purely static site or a Jamstack-based project that benefits from built-in features like forms, identity management, and easy serverless functions.
Netlify's ecosystem is particularly friendly for developers working with static site generators like Gatsby, Jekyll, or Hugo.
Its plugin-based architecture and ease of use make it a great choice for small to medium-sized projects.
- ** Use Vercel ** - if you are working with Next.js or other dynamic front-end frameworks that require features like Incremental Static Regeneration (ISR) and server-side rendering (SSR).
Vercel is built for performance-driven applications, making it ideal for startups and large-scale applications that need edge functions, faster dynamic deployments, and real-time data handling.

## Final thoughts
Both platforms offer exceptional performance, automatic deployments, and global CDN support, making them excellent choices for modern web development. The decision comes down to your project requirements:
-If you prioritize static-first architecture, Netlify is the better choice.
-If you need advanced rendering and performance optimizations, Vercel is the way to go.

As both platforms continue to evolve, they are adding new features that blur the lines between static and dynamic hosting.
The future of web development is leaning toward edge computing, serverless functions, and hybrid rendering, areas where both Netlify and Vercel are making significant advancements.

Ultimately, choosing between Netlify and Vercel depends on your stack, scalability needs, and the type of application you are building.

## References
Netlify Official Site - https://www.netlify.com/

Vercel Official Site - https://vercel.com/

Jamstack.org - https://jamstack.org/

## Additional Resources

Netlify vs. Vercel: Which Frontend Cloud Platform Delivers Best Performance? – A detailed performance comparison by Bejamas - https://bejamas.com/compare/netlify-vs-vercel?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Vercel vs. Netlify: Battle of the Composable Web Platforms – A feature and pricing comparison by Ikius - https://ikius.com/blog/vercel-vs-netlify?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Netlify vs. Vercel: A Comparison – Insights on deployment workflows and serverless functions by Max Niederman on DEV Community - https://dev.to/maxniederman/netlify-vs-vercel-a-comparison-5643?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Vercel vs. Netlify: How to Pick the Right Platform – A comparison of both platforms, focusing on scalability and best use cases - https://focusreactive.com/vercel-vs-netlify-how-to-pick-the-right-platform/?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Jamstack Deployment & Hosting: Vercel vs. Netlify – An in-depth breakdown of features, deployment speeds, and build times by Snipcart - https://snipcart.com/blog/vercel-vs-netlify?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Vercel vs. Netlify: A Comprehensive Comparison for Static Site Hosting – A Medium article covering deployment workflows and pricing structures - https://medium.com/%40YAKStack/vercel-vs-netlify-a-comprehensive-comparison-for-static-site-hosting-21a2f0b716f2?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Netlify vs. Render vs. Vercel – A comparison of Netlify, Vercel, and Render, focusing on features, infrastructure, and CI/CD - https://bejamas.com/compare/netlify-vs-render-vs-vercel?utm_source=chatgpt.com