Bootstrap orchestrate and skills management skills#164
Conversation
pdettori
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Orchestration review: LGTM
Replicate phase reviewed. 13 skills bootstrapped with clean adaptation. All frontmatter valid, no broken cross-references, no kagenti-specific content remaining.
Fix applied: Generalized example commands and org-specific workflow reference (7f0bf2b).
mrsabath
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Review Summary
Well-structured Phase 6 replication that bootstraps 13 orchestration and skills management skills into agent-examples. All skill files have proper YAML frontmatter with matching names, consistent structure (mermaid diagrams, When to Use, Related Skills), and no broken cross-references.
Areas reviewed: Skills structure, cross-references, kagenti-specific content, security
Commits: 2 commits, both signed-off ✓, Assisted-By ✓
CI status: all passing ✓
Findings:
-
/tmp/kagenti/hardcoded paths (suggestion): The temp directory pattern/tmp/kagenti/orchestrate/and/tmp/kagenti/skills-scan/appears in ~14 locations across the skill files. Since these are now in agent-examples (not kagenti), consider renaming to/tmp/orchestrate/or parameterizing in a follow-up. Functional as-is. -
Minor kagenti references (nit):
skills:validatetask example useskagentias worktree nameorchestrate:scanusestest_keycloak.pyas illustrative example
-
Skill length (nit):
orchestrate:scan(488 lines) andorchestrate:ci(401 lines) exceed the 300-line recommended max fromskills:validate. Could split in future.
No issues found with:
- Skill cross-references (all 13 skills reference only valid siblings)
- Security (no secrets, tokens, or credentials)
- Frontmatter validity and naming consistency
- Commit conventions and sign-off
LGTM — clean adaptation with the fractal orchestration concept intact.
Replicate Phase 6: copy orchestrate skills into agent-examples, making it self-sufficient for orchestrating its own related repos. Skills added: - orchestrate (router) + scan, plan, precommit, tests, ci, security, replicate, review - skills (router) + scan, write, validate All skills adapted for standalone use: - Removed kagenti-specific references and hub-specific language - Removed references to non-copied skills (tdd:ci, rca:ci, cve:*, etc.) - Updated Related Skills sections to only reference available skills - Generalized command patterns and category lists Also updates CLAUDE.md with orchestration section and .gitignore with .repos/ pattern. Assisted-By: Claude (Anthropic AI) <noreply@anthropic.com> Signed-off-by: Paolo Dettori <dettori@us.ibm.com>
Replace kagenti-system/mlflow examples with generic my-namespace/my-app in skills:validate and skills:write. Replace kagenti org reusable workflow reference with generic <org> placeholder in orchestrate:ci. Assisted-By: Claude (Anthropic AI) <noreply@anthropic.com> Signed-off-by: Paolo Dettori <dettori@us.ibm.com>
7f0bf2b to
c6b4da7
Compare
Summary
Phase 6 of repository orchestration. Makes agent-examples self-sufficient for orchestrating other repos.
13 skills added (9 orchestrate + 4 skills management):
orchestrate(router),scan,plan,precommit,tests,ci,security,replicate,reviewskills(router),scan,write,validateAll skills adapted for standalone use:
Also:
CLAUDE.mdwith orchestration section.repos/to.gitignoreThe fractal concept
With these skills, agent-examples can now orchestrate other repos through the same phased approach: scan → plan → precommit → tests → ci → security → replicate.
Test plan
/orchestrate statusworks from agent-examples context