Skip to content

Conversation

@amanstep
Copy link
Collaborator

@amanstep amanstep commented Feb 3, 2026

No description provided.

@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Feb 3, 2026

Claude finished @amanstep's task —— View job


Comprehensive GitHub Action Review

Reviewing this pull request for GitHub Action compliance and security requirements.

Review Progress:

  • Determine action type (node/docker/composite)
  • Check license and copyright requirements
  • Verify action.yml structure and author
  • Check required file presence (SECURITY.md, workflows)
  • Verify forbidden files are absent
  • Check README.md version usage examples
  • Verify subscription check implementation
  • Scan for security vulnerabilities
  • Check node-specific requirements
  • Check docker-specific requirements
  • Provide final recommendations

Action Type Analysis

This is a Hybrid Action with both Node.js and Docker implementations:

  • Primary: Node.js action (action.yml using node20)
  • Secondary: Docker action (docker/action.yml using ../Dockerfile)

PASSED REQUIREMENTS

License & Copyright

  • ✅ LICENSE file present with correct StepSecurity copyright (LICENSE:4)
  • ✅ Original author copyright preserved (LICENSE:3)
  • ✅ ISC license matches original

Action Configuration

  • action.yml has correct author: step-security (action.yml:3)
  • docker/action.yml has correct author: step-security (docker/action.yml:3)

Required Files Present

  • ✅ SECURITY.md present with correct contact (SECURITY.md:5)
  • .github/workflows/auto_cherry_pick.yml present
  • .github/workflows/actions_release.yml present

Forbidden Files Absent

  • ✅ No FUNDING.yml or funding.yml files
  • ✅ No renovate.json file
  • ✅ No PULL_REQUEST.md file
  • ✅ No ISSUE_TEMPLATE folder
  • ✅ No CHANGELOG.md file
  • ✅ No .vscode folder (correctly ignored in .gitignore)

Package.json (Node-specific)

  • ✅ Author: step-security (package.json:6)
  • ✅ Repository contains step-security phrase (package.json:10)
  • ✅ Build script present: ncc build action.js (package.json:13)

Distribution

  • dist/ folder present for Node.js action

Version Usage Examples

  • ✅ README.md uses major version only: @v6 (README.md:50)

Subscription Check Implementation

  • EXCELLENT: Proper subscription validation implemented (index.js:17-32)
    • Correct API URL: https://agent.api.stepsecurity.io/v1/github/${process.env.GITHUB_REPOSITORY}/actions/subscription
    • Proper error handling for 403 responses
    • Graceful timeout handling for unreachable API
    • Called in main drafter function (index.js:152)

⚠️ ISSUES IDENTIFIED

Docker Implementation Concerns

  • CRITICAL: Docker action uses local Dockerfile instead of published image (docker/action.yml:6)
    • Uses: image: '../Dockerfile'
    • Should use: image: docker://stepsecurity/release-drafter:v6
  • CRITICAL: Dockerfile uses base image instead of StepSecurity published image
    • Current: FROM node:20.11.0-alpine@sha256:9b61ed13fef9ca689326f40c0c0b4da70e37a18712f200b4c66d3b44fd59d98e
    • Should use StepSecurity org published image

Workflows Configuration

  • ⚠️ WARNING: actions_release.yml has build script commented out (actions_release.yml:10-13)
    • Since package.json has build script, workflow should specify it as input
    • Current state may work but violates standard practice

🔍 SECURITY ANALYSIS

Code Security Review

  • NO CRITICAL VULNERABILITIES DETECTED
  • ✅ Template system uses safe string replacement (lib/template.js:10-28)
  • ✅ Regex parsing properly validated (lib/template.js:36-50)
  • ✅ No dangerous functions (eval, exec, Function()) in source code
  • ✅ File operations limited to test fixtures and build scripts
  • ✅ All dependencies appear used and necessary
  • ✅ Input validation present for configuration

Dependency Analysis

  • ✅ All major dependencies verified as used:
    • @actions/core ✓ (index.js:12)
    • axios ✓ (index.js:15)
    • probot ✓ (action.js:2)
    • lodash, semver, joi etc. all referenced

📋 RECOMMENDATIONS

High Priority

  1. Fix Docker Implementation: Update docker/action.yml to use published Docker image from StepSecurity org
  2. Publish Docker Image: Ensure Docker image is published to StepSecurity registry with proper major version tag

Medium Priority

  1. Update Workflow: Uncomment and specify build script in actions_release.yml

Low Priority

  1. Consider: Add input validation for action inputs in action.yml

📊 COMPLIANCE SCORE: 8.5/10

Summary: This is a well-implemented GitHub Action with excellent security practices, proper StepSecurity branding, and comprehensive subscription checking. The main issues are with the Docker implementation not following the published image requirement. The Node.js implementation meets all requirements excellently.

@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Feb 3, 2026

Claude finished @amanstep's task —— View job


Comprehensive GitHub Action Review

Reviewing this pull request for GitHub Action compliance and security requirements.

Review Progress:

  • Determine action type (node/docker/composite)
  • Check license and copyright requirements
  • Verify action.yml structure and author
  • Check required file presence (SECURITY.md, workflows)
  • Verify forbidden files are absent
  • Check README.md version usage examples
  • Verify subscription check implementation
  • Scan for security vulnerabilities
  • Check node-specific requirements
  • Check docker-specific requirements
  • Provide final recommendations

Action Type Analysis

This is a Hybrid Action with both Node.js and Docker implementations:

  • Primary: Node.js action (action.yml using node20)
  • Secondary: Docker action (docker/action.yml using ../Dockerfile)

PASSED REQUIREMENTS

License & Copyright

  • ✅ LICENSE file present with correct StepSecurity copyright (LICENSE:4)
  • ✅ Original author copyright preserved (LICENSE:3)
  • ✅ ISC license matches original

Action Configuration

  • action.yml has correct author: step-security (action.yml:3)
  • docker/action.yml has correct author: step-security (docker/action.yml:3)

Required Files Present

  • ✅ SECURITY.md present with correct contact (SECURITY.md:5)
  • .github/workflows/auto_cherry_pick.yml present
  • .github/workflows/actions_release.yml present

Forbidden Files Absent

  • ✅ No FUNDING.yml or funding.yml files
  • ✅ No renovate.json file
  • ✅ No PULL_REQUEST.md file
  • ✅ No ISSUE_TEMPLATE folder
  • ✅ No CHANGELOG.md file
  • ✅ No .vscode folder (correctly ignored in .gitignore)

Package.json (Node-specific)

  • ✅ Author: step-security (package.json:6)
  • ✅ Repository contains step-security phrase (package.json:10)
  • ✅ Build script present: ncc build action.js (package.json:13)

Distribution

  • dist/ folder present for Node.js action

Version Usage Examples

  • ✅ README.md uses major version only: @v6 (README.md:50)

Subscription Check Implementation

  • EXCELLENT: Proper subscription validation implemented (index.js:17-32)
    • Correct API URL: https://agent.api.stepsecurity.io/v1/github/${process.env.GITHUB_REPOSITORY}/actions/subscription
    • Proper error handling for 403 responses
    • Graceful timeout handling for unreachable API
    • Called in main drafter function (index.js:152)

⚠️ ISSUES IDENTIFIED

Docker Implementation Concerns

  • CRITICAL: Docker action uses local Dockerfile instead of published image (docker/action.yml:6)
    • Uses: image: '../Dockerfile'
    • Should use: image: docker://stepsecurity/release-drafter:v6
  • CRITICAL: Dockerfile uses base image instead of StepSecurity published image
    • Current: FROM node:20.11.0-alpine@sha256:9b61ed13fef9ca689326f40c0c0b4da70e37a18712f200b4c66d3b44fd59d98e
    • Should use StepSecurity org published image

Workflows Configuration

  • ⚠️ WARNING: actions_release.yml has build script commented out (actions_release.yml:10-13)
    • Since package.json has build script, workflow should specify it as input
    • Current state may work but violates standard practice

🔍 SECURITY ANALYSIS

Code Security Review

  • NO CRITICAL VULNERABILITIES DETECTED
  • ✅ Template system uses safe string replacement (lib/template.js:10-28)
  • ✅ Regex parsing properly validated (lib/template.js:36-50)
  • ✅ No dangerous functions (eval, exec, Function()) in source code
  • ✅ File operations limited to test fixtures and build scripts
  • ✅ All dependencies appear used and necessary
  • ✅ Input validation present for configuration

Dependency Analysis

  • ✅ All major dependencies verified as used:
    • @actions/core ✓ (index.js:12)
    • axios ✓ (index.js:15)
    • probot ✓ (action.js:2)
    • lodash, semver, joi etc. all referenced

📋 RECOMMENDATIONS

High Priority

  1. Fix Docker Implementation: Update docker/action.yml to use published Docker image from StepSecurity org
  2. Publish Docker Image: Ensure Docker image is published to StepSecurity registry with proper major version tag

Medium Priority

  1. Update Workflow: Uncomment and specify build script in actions_release.yml

Low Priority

  1. Consider: Add input validation for action inputs in action.yml

📊 COMPLIANCE SCORE: 8.5/10

Summary: This is a well-implemented GitHub Action with excellent security practices, proper StepSecurity branding, and comprehensive subscription checking. The main issues are with the Docker implementation not following the published image requirement. The Node.js implementation meets all requirements excellently.


@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Feb 3, 2026

Claude finished @amanstep's task —— View job


Comprehensive GitHub Action Review

Reviewing this pull request for GitHub Action compliance and security requirements.

Review Progress:

  • Determine action type (node/docker/composite)
  • Check license and copyright requirements
  • Verify action.yml structure and author
  • Check required file presence (SECURITY.md, workflows)
  • Verify forbidden files are absent
  • Check README.md version usage examples
  • Verify subscription check implementation
  • Scan for security vulnerabilities
  • Check node-specific requirements
  • Check docker-specific requirements
  • Provide final recommendations

Action Type Analysis

This is a Hybrid Action with both Node.js and Docker implementations:

  • Primary: Node.js action (action.yml using node20)
  • Secondary: Docker action (docker/action.yml using ../Dockerfile)

PASSED REQUIREMENTS

License & Copyright

  • ✅ LICENSE file present with correct StepSecurity copyright (LICENSE:4)
  • ✅ Original author copyright preserved (LICENSE:3)
  • ✅ ISC license matches original

Action Configuration

  • action.yml has correct author: step-security (action.yml:3)
  • docker/action.yml has correct author: step-security (docker/action.yml:3)

Required Files Present

  • ✅ SECURITY.md present with correct contact (SECURITY.md:5)
  • .github/workflows/auto_cherry_pick.yml present
  • .github/workflows/actions_release.yml present

Forbidden Files Absent

  • ✅ No FUNDING.yml or funding.yml files
  • ✅ No renovate.json file
  • ✅ No PULL_REQUEST.md file
  • ✅ No ISSUE_TEMPLATE folder
  • ✅ No CHANGELOG.md file
  • ✅ No .vscode folder (correctly ignored in .gitignore)

Package.json (Node-specific)

  • ✅ Author: step-security (package.json:6)
  • ✅ Repository contains step-security phrase (package.json:10)
  • ✅ Build script present: ncc build action.js (package.json:13)

Distribution

  • dist/ folder present for Node.js action

Version Usage Examples

  • ✅ README.md uses major version only: @v6 (README.md:50)

Subscription Check Implementation

  • EXCELLENT: Proper subscription validation implemented (index.js:17-32)
    • Correct API URL: https://agent.api.stepsecurity.io/v1/github/${process.env.GITHUB_REPOSITORY}/actions/subscription
    • Proper error handling for 403 responses
    • Graceful timeout handling for unreachable API
    • Called in main drafter function (index.js:152)

⚠️ ISSUES IDENTIFIED

Docker Implementation Concerns

  • CRITICAL: Docker action uses local Dockerfile instead of published image (docker/action.yml:6)
    • Uses: image: '../Dockerfile'
    • Should use: image: docker://stepsecurity/release-drafter:v6
  • CRITICAL: Dockerfile uses base image instead of StepSecurity published image
    • Current: FROM node:20.11.0-alpine@sha256:9b61ed13fef9ca689326f40c0c0b4da70e37a18712f200b4c66d3b44fd59d98e
    • Should use StepSecurity org published image

Workflows Configuration

  • ⚠️ WARNING: actions_release.yml uses reusable workflow but doesn't specify build script input (actions_release.yml:20-22)
    • Since package.json has build script, workflow should specify it as input
    • Current state may work but violates standard practice

🔍 SECURITY ANALYSIS

Code Security Review

  • NO CRITICAL VULNERABILITIES DETECTED
  • ✅ Template system uses safe string replacement (lib/template.js:10-28)
  • ✅ Regex parsing properly validated (lib/template.js:36-50)
  • ✅ No dangerous functions (eval, exec, Function()) in source code
  • ✅ File operations limited to test fixtures and build scripts
  • ✅ All dependencies appear used and necessary
  • ✅ Input validation present for configuration

Dependency Analysis

  • ✅ All major dependencies verified as used:
    • @actions/core ✓ (index.js:12)
    • axios ✓ (index.js:15)
    • probot ✓ (action.js:2)
    • lodash, semver, joi etc. all referenced

📋 RECOMMENDATIONS

High Priority

  1. Fix Docker Implementation: Update docker/action.yml to use published Docker image from StepSecurity org
  2. Publish Docker Image: Ensure Docker image is published to StepSecurity registry with proper major version tag

Medium Priority

  1. Update Workflow: Specify build script in actions_release.yml inputs for consistency

Low Priority

  1. Consider: Add input validation for action inputs in action.yml

📊 COMPLIANCE SCORE: 8.5/10

Summary: This is a well-implemented GitHub Action with excellent security practices, proper StepSecurity branding, and comprehensive subscription checking. The main issues are with the Docker implementation not following the published image requirement. The Node.js implementation meets all requirements excellently.


@claude
Copy link

claude bot commented Feb 3, 2026

Claude finished @amanstep's task —— View job


Comprehensive GitHub Action Review

Reviewing this pull request for GitHub Action compliance and security requirements.

Review Progress:

  • Determine action type (node/docker/composite)
  • Check license and copyright requirements
  • Verify action.yml structure and author
  • Check required file presence (SECURITY.md, workflows)
  • Verify forbidden files are absent
  • Check README.md version usage examples
  • Verify subscription check implementation
  • Scan for security vulnerabilities
  • Check node-specific requirements
  • Check docker-specific requirements
  • Provide final recommendations

Action Type Analysis

This is a Hybrid Action with both Node.js and Docker implementations:

  • Primary: Node.js action (action.yml using node20)
  • Secondary: Docker action (docker/action.yml using ../Dockerfile)

PASSED REQUIREMENTS

License & Copyright

  • ✅ LICENSE file present with correct StepSecurity copyright (LICENSE:4)
  • ✅ Original author copyright preserved (LICENSE:3)
  • ✅ ISC license matches original

Action Configuration

  • action.yml has correct author: step-security (action.yml:3)
  • docker/action.yml has correct author: step-security (docker/action.yml:3)

Required Files Present

  • ✅ SECURITY.md present with correct contact (SECURITY.md:5)
  • .github/workflows/auto_cherry_pick.yml present
  • .github/workflows/actions_release.yml present

Forbidden Files Absent

  • ✅ No FUNDING.yml or funding.yml files
  • ✅ No renovate.json file
  • ✅ No PULL_REQUEST.md file
  • ✅ No ISSUE_TEMPLATE folder
  • ✅ No CHANGELOG.md file
  • ✅ No .vscode folder (correctly ignored in .gitignore)

Package.json (Node-specific)

  • ✅ Author: step-security (package.json:6)
  • ✅ Repository contains step-security phrase (package.json:10)
  • ✅ Build script present: ncc build action.js (package.json:13)

Distribution

  • dist/ folder present for Node.js action

Version Usage Examples

  • ✅ README.md uses major version only: @v6 (README.md:50)

Subscription Check Implementation

  • EXCELLENT: Proper subscription validation implemented (index.js:17-32)
    • Correct API URL: https://agent.api.stepsecurity.io/v1/github/${process.env.GITHUB_REPOSITORY}/actions/subscription
    • Proper error handling for 403 responses
    • Graceful timeout handling for unreachable API
    • Called in main drafter function (index.js:152)

⚠️ ISSUES IDENTIFIED

Docker Implementation Concerns

  • CRITICAL: Docker action uses local Dockerfile instead of published image (docker/action.yml:6)
    • Uses: image: '../Dockerfile'
    • Should use: image: docker://stepsecurity/release-drafter:v6
  • CRITICAL: Dockerfile uses base image instead of StepSecurity published image
    • Current: FROM node:20.11.0-alpine@sha256:9b61ed13fef9ca689326f40c0c0b4da70e37a18712f200b4c66d3b44fd59d98e
    • Should use StepSecurity org published image

Workflows Configuration

  • ⚠️ WARNING: actions_release.yml uses reusable workflow but doesn't specify build script input (actions_release.yml:20-22)
    • Since package.json has build script, workflow should specify it as input
    • Current state may work but violates standard practice

🔍 SECURITY ANALYSIS

Code Security Review

  • NO CRITICAL VULNERABILITIES DETECTED
  • ✅ Template system uses safe string replacement (lib/template.js:10-28)
  • ✅ Regex parsing properly validated (lib/template.js:36-50)
  • ✅ No dangerous functions (eval, exec, Function()) in source code
  • ✅ File operations limited to test fixtures and build scripts
  • ✅ All dependencies appear used and necessary
  • ✅ Input validation present for configuration

Dependency Analysis

  • ✅ All major dependencies verified as used:
    • @actions/core ✓ (index.js:12)
    • axios ✓ (index.js:15)
    • probot ✓ (action.js:2)
    • lodash, semver, joi etc. all referenced

📋 RECOMMENDATIONS

High Priority

  1. Fix Docker Implementation: Update docker/action.yml to use published Docker image from StepSecurity org
  2. Publish Docker Image: Ensure Docker image is published to StepSecurity registry with proper major version tag

Medium Priority

  1. Update Workflow: Specify build script in actions_release.yml inputs for consistency

Low Priority

  1. Consider: Add input validation for action inputs in action.yml

📊 COMPLIANCE SCORE: 8.5/10

Summary: This is a well-implemented GitHub Action with excellent security practices, proper StepSecurity branding, and comprehensive subscription checking. The main issues are with the Docker implementation not following the published image requirement. The Node.js implementation meets all requirements excellently.


@@ -0,0 +1,19 @@
name: Node & npm setup
author: Clément Chanchevrier @cchanche

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

remove author

"generate-fixtures": "node ./bin/generate-fixtures.js",
"lint": "eslint bin/*.js lib/*.js action.js index.js test/**/*.js",
"prettier": "prettier --write **/*.{js,md,json}",
"postversion": "npm run test && git push && git push --tags",

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

remove

"lint": "eslint bin/*.js lib/*.js action.js index.js test/**/*.js",
"prettier": "prettier --write **/*.{js,md,json}",
"postversion": "npm run test && git push && git push --tags",
"open-releases": "open \"$(node -e 'console.log(`${require(\"./package.json\").repository}/releases`)')\""

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

check usage and remove

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

remove lib folder from tracking

@Raj-StepSecurity
Copy link

add publish docker image workflow

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants